That's exactly it. He's just so adorably dorky when he finally does the right thing and gets Peter to forgive him for whatever douchebaggery he did before. But now he can't anymore. We just have the Sylar!clone. Which is weird. And creepy. And weird. It's just going to hurt Peter so much when he finds out that not only is Nathan dead, but the guy he's been treating like his brother is the man who killed him. Doesn't Peter deserve some happiness after all the shit he's had to go through? The poor guy doesn't smile anymore.

well, he did during that scene, which I squeed all over because he was so perfect as he leaned back in the seat with that grin of satisfaction at finally nabbing Sylar. Hee hee. I loved that line, too. Even Claude would have laughed.

Precisely. They need to start dealing with the corners they write themselves into instead of ignoring them altogether.

I could handle it in season 1, but since that brain rape thing, I can't take it. I'm not easily squicked by stuff, but seeing that was way too much for me to handle.